Pamela Lynne Neal was born on July 18, 1960, and graduated from Cherry Creek High School in Greenwood Village, Colorado, in 1978. Following high school, she attended Western State College at Gunnison before heading to Alaska for a year. She later went to Maine with her parents and returned to Colorado, where she landed a bank teller job with Key Savings and Loan, 3501 South Broadway in Englewood.
On March 31, 1983, Pamela left work on her lunch break at 1:30 p.m. and walked two blocks east to another bank to cash a check. She withdrew several hundred dollars and stuffed the money into her coat pocket. Afterward, she stopped at a Safeway grocery store to buy a lottery ticket, a pack of Winston cigarettes, and a delicatessen lunch.
Pamela then walked to her third-floor apartment at 9 Hamden Avenue, across the street from her employer, to eat lunch before returning to work. She did not own a car. When Pamela did not return to work, her co-worker and roommate, Darlene Heintz, called the apartment at 2:30 p.m. When there was no answer, Darlene walked to the apartment. Darlene later told the police that she saw Pamela walking towards their apartment. One other witness also saw Pamela.
When Darlene arrived, the entrance door was ajar. She called her boss, who then called the police.
Police arrived and entered the apartment. Pamela’s lunch – a piece of fried chicken and a macaroni and cheese side dish – sat in an unopened bag on the coffee table. Her shoes were under the coffee table, and her keys were on the floor. She usually tossed the keys onto a chair.
The lottery ticket she purchased at Safeway was still inside her wallet in her purse next to the coffee table. Pamela had not scratched off the lottery ticket, and the unopened pack of Winston’s and a half-pack were left behind.
There were no signs of a struggle; however, all signs pointed toward an abduction. Neighbors did not see or hear anything unusual, and a thorough search of her apartment showed no evidence of her disappearance.
Despite a massive search and investigation into Pamela’s abduction, she was never found. Her case is listed as a homicide, not a missing person’s case.
A couple of theories emerged about Pamela’s disappearance.
- The main one is that someone followed Pamela into her apartment, kidnapped her, and then forced the young woman down two flights of stairs.
- The other theory is that Pamela ran down to get her mail, and someone grabbed her there.
Nine months after Pamela’s disappearance, Melissa Lou Chase, 17, was found beaten to death under a bridge in Englewood on December 8, 1983. Her live-in boyfriend was the one who found her body. He was never named in news reports. The last time Melissa was seen alive was around 5:30 p.m. the night before, after she had finished her shift at Phillips 66 service station at Union Avenue and Broadway.
Three years before Pamela disappeared, 21-year-old Helene Pruszynski was found murdered on January 18, 1980. She was nude below the waist, and her hands were bound behind her back. She had been raped repeatedly and stabbed nine times in her back.
Pruszynski had established a pattern in which she would leave work at the radio station at 16th and Broadway in Denver and catch a bus around 6:10 p.m. at Broadway and 14th Avenue. She would ride south until she got off at South Broadway and Union Avenue. (Mitchell 2017)
Like Helene, Melissa was found nude below the waist, although there was no evidence of a sexual assault. Melissa had also disappeared the night before her body was found.
Two weeks before Helene’s murder, another young girl was sexually assaulted after getting off a bus on South Broadway.
In March 1968, Constance Marie Paris, 18, had also been attacked, sexually assaulted, and strangled. She went missing after getting off a bus at South Broadway and Girard Avenue. Her body was found days later in southwest Denver.
The main suspect in Helene’s case is Kenyon Battles Tolerton. He is currently incarcerated for the 1993 rape and murder of a 14-year-old. Police considered Tolerton a person of interest in Pamela’s case until investigators discovered he had been in prison for another crime at the time of her disappearance.
If you have any information in this case, please call the Englewood Police Department at (303) 762-2460.
Mitchell, Kirk. “Englewood Bank Teller Vanishes On Lunch Break”. The Denver Post 2014. Web. 3 June 2017.
Mitchell, Kirk. “Englewood KHOW Radio Intern Kidnapped”. The Denver Post 2014. Web. 3 June 2017.
Mitchell, Kirk. “Englewood girl beaten to death, dumped partially nude under bridge”. The Denver Post 2013. Web. 3 June 2017.
True Crime Diva’s Thoughts
The first thing that stood out for me in Pamela’s case was the wad of bills Pamela stuffed into her coat pocket. If someone at the bank saw her do this, he could have followed her home with the intent to rob her but something else transpired.
The person could have been known to Pamela and knew her daily routine. He would know when she left to go to lunch and would also know that she went home to eat it. A co-worker?
Pamela’s lunch, keys, and shoes were there so we know she made it inside her apartment. The abductor most likely broke in or knocked on the door and forced his way through. There were no signs of a struggle but her family stated she would not have resisted.
There was also no evidence found inside Pamela’s apartment, so the crime most likely did not happen there. Her abductor must have taken her elsewhere.
From what I understand, Hamden Avenue was and is a very busy street, so I am amazed that someone was able to kidnap her without anyone noticing. I’m thinking she willingly went with him. I’m sure he had a weapon and that alone would probably keep her compliant.
There are many similarities between Pamela and Helene’s case. Both girls were in their early 20s with brown hair, and both disappeared at or near their homes. They were around the same height and weight, too. However, Helene disappeared at night and Pamela in broad daylight. Police also think Tolerton killed Helene, but there is a chance he did not, and that another sexual predator was roaming the streets of Englewood in the 1980s.
While I think it’s a little possible that Melissa’s case is related, I am under the impression that her boyfriend was a person of interest. It really makes the most sense in her case. However Melissa worked at a gas station at the same intersection Helene would have stepped off the bus from to go home – Union Avenue and South Broadway. This intersection is only about two and a half miles from Pamela’s apartment.
Is it possible that Melissa’s boyfriend killed her, Pamela and Helene? Maybe Melissa found out about Pamela and Helene so he killed her. There was no sexual assault on Melissa. She was beaten viciously – kicked in the head – and that sounds more domestic and/or personal to me. Maybe she threatened to go to the police.
Tolerton does seem like a good suspect in Helene’s case but he was imprisoned at the time of Pamela’s disappearance. Those two cases are too similar to rule out a connection, in my opinion.
What do you think happened to Pamela Lynn Neal?